Orvin Kimbrough

Orvin Kimbrough is chairman and CEO of Midwest BankCentre.

Even though the death of Mr. George Floyd occurred in late May, the protest continues.  It’s about George Floyd’s fate and so much more—it’s about the many eyes that are now wide open after witnessing a Black man’s murder under the knee of systems that have been failing so many for so long. It’s about a demand to those of us who are privileged to commit to equitable dispensation of power, justice and economics. These are the very issues that the late Rep. John Lewis – a civil rights icon took beating after beating for and continued to work for throughout his life as a Congressman.

Many colleagues locally and nationally within my network have reached out to ask my opinion on a way forward and to memorialize how they might affect significant change. There are many more questions than I have answers: Is this a watershed moment where we tackle arguably our country's thorniest issue? I hope so. While race is a social construct that some have the privilege not to see, I see the impact of race every day. In the pages that follow, I will provide some personal insights into our current moment and what we as corporate leaders can do to ensure that we don’t waste this crisis.

Our current moment – equity 

I continue to get comments and questions from my White colleagues along this line. “I am generally a good person. Is this my problem to solve or is it beyond me?” My answer is consistent and simple: Yes, it is your problem.  Racism, defined as a systemic allocation of resources that doles out influence, justice and economic opportunity based on skin color, clearly exists and influences every aspect of one’s life.

I believe that there is shared responsibility and accountability to find solutions to these life-arresting challenges, particularly among those who are in a position to influence our systems and to effect meaningful change. Not only is it the right thing to do, not only will racial equity exert a powerful positive influence on the lives and futures of our children, it’s an economic imperative for the future of our country. By 2050, our country stands to realize an $8 trillion gain in GDP by closing the US racial equity gap. “Closing the gap” means lessening, and ultimately eliminating, disparities and opportunity differentials that limit human potential and economic contributions of people of color.   

I have heard it stated that equity is about each of us getting what we need to survive or succeed—access to opportunity, networks, capital, and supports—based on where we are and where we want to go.  Equity is also about ownership. It's hard for Black and Brown people to be invested in local communities when we don't own much. Is there a linear path to equity? Absolutely not. We have to be willing to accept that our systems are complex and we will need to apply energy and pressure to match that complexity without throwing our hands up in defeat because it is difficult.

What corporate leaders can do

 I often talk about the three-legged stool made up of government, charity and business that share equal parts shaping our democracy. When there is a crisis or potential watershed moment, such as we are seeing now, there is a general tendency to shift more of the burden onto charity in an effort to do something quick. In this case, charity becomes an elixir. While I appreciate the desire to act quickly through charitable investments, this alone will not achieve our desired goal of equitable outcomes for more people. Let’s do the right “something.” The right something means thinking about and engaging in a range of high-impact activities that are tied to shared prosperity.  

It’s about more than writing checks

In my mind, charity has always been one of three industries that are important to transforming life and improving any democracy. In my nearly 13 years of service to United Way, our region has always held one of the top 2-3 positions in terms of most charitable regions in the US. Organizations in our local region will proudly attest to the fact that they are ranked in the top five nationally in their category, and people who move to St. Louis will often comment about the “generosity” of the region. And yet, when it comes to outcomes for poor and marginalized communities, particularly Black and Brown, our region ranks at the bottom on almost any measure that you care to analyze. Charity is an elixir because there is no correlation in the magnitude of charitable investments and the outcomes of citizens; yet, we are content to celebrate this year in and year out without calling long-term impact into question. 

An elixir by its very nature is meant to numb you. It is meant to dull your senses. My plea is that we not be satisfied to simply write checks, and those of us on the receiving end not be seduced and sedated into simply taking the money without a sustainable path forward. All communities need access to education and capital to thrive. Minorities need to demand these tools, and those in power need to personally commit to do our part to help more people succeed. Finally, we need to demand that charitable organizations that do receive our funding be held accountable to verifiable outcomes.

A Commitment to Diverse and Inclusive Economic Environment Starts at the Top

We have chosen for generations not to see the humanity of all people. We have failed to consistently advance policies that promote justice. We have failed to address, in any serious way, the systems that continue to produce economic deserts and the means for upward mobility.

So much has been said about wealth and income disparity. As a capitalist country, most of us are not so much concerned about how much people make. That said, many of us want to ensure that systems are not rigged to advantage any one group over another. We are concerned that we have reached a point where the uneven distribution of wealth and earnings is at a level that will erode our nation’s competitiveness. We are also concerned that what makes our nation the greatest experiment in history, our diversity, is being undermined by a scarcity mentality by those who have the most in terms of material possessions.

At Midwest BankCentre, we embrace and foster diversity, not just because it’s the right thing to do, but also because it makes good business sense. By embracing diversity in people, geography and products, we spark innovation that allows us to better understand and serve all of our customers. Our commitment to diversity and inclusion starts at the top, with an executive team that is 70% diverse. I believe this helps us better serve all of the St. Louis region.

We also have one of the most diverse boards in Missouri, unlike many you’ll see across the nation. Our board reflects our values, and the strategy that is important to the future of the bank. 

Leadership is key to the success of an organization’s diversity and inclusion efforts. Choose your leader(s) wisely, and understand the key characteristics to success in the role: they must be an advocate, a bridge builder, a unifier, a consensus builder, and above all, tenacious.  If they are doing their job right, they may make people uncomfortable by pushing boundaries while simultaneously building deep relationships and formidable allies to achieve progress.

Help others occupy your space 

When you are disappointed time and again, you develop a learned helplessness. Unsure of what you can do to “exercise personal agency” as society expects, you fall into a depression. Once you are depressed, you are bereft of hope and you give up. The real tragedy is that, even when you see the system that is working against you, it is virtually impossible in your own strength to muster enough energy to prevail. You need allies. 

As a leader in your organization, you have to help with the “wind in the face” challenge that so many Black and Brown people experience. You have to ask questions and challenge the process to ensure that the implicit bias inherent in any organization is managed. This is what being a true ally looks like.

Most know that I spent nearly 20 years in the charitable sector, concluding that journey as CEO of United Way in the St. Louis region. What makes that miraculous for me, is that as a young person I lived at two orphanages and utilized the free resources offered by many organizations United Way funded. My rise to the CEO of this organization was and still is improbable, as I came from what many consider the economic gutter. But I had a champion and ally in the former CEO, Gary Dollar, who happens to be white, and who challenged me to be better. He actively advocated for me. He and several racially diverse influential members of the community were my allies and advocates. Our collective responsibility is now to provide sponsorship for others.

For a whole host of reasons, oftentimes racial minorities move into certain powerful positions and choose not to use their voice on justice and equity issues because it is “what is expected of us” and it’s not necessarily met with a warm reception. I believe we have to push beyond the “stereotype-cast” pressure we feel, because we have a responsibility to use our platform to help others. Our versatility in speaking to multiple issues, including race and equity, will create tremendous value for the enterprise.  We must occupy our space. 

Company culture and community building

A McKinsey survey found that only one in three organizational efforts succeeds with culture change, often having even lower odds of success. The people who need to change their behavior typically have a clear sense of the costs of doing so, whereas the benefits of a “new culture” can seem fuzzy.

If you are launching a community planning effort focused on economic inclusiveness, equity and diversity, be sure that the volunteer committee and those who are paid to facilitate the process are gender and racially diverse. Focus the group's energies on high-impact and high-leverage activity sets.  Their contributions need to be meaningful and measurable to be sustainable. Engage your executive team and a volunteer committee to really develop a culture that is inclusive.

Make the time to understand and demystify “the systems” that marginalized groups speak about. 

Create a safe space for marginalized groups to share their experiences, but don’t create an expectation that they educate you.

Be open to hearing. Operate in the uncomfortable zone longer than you typically would, and do not withdraw.

Read three books about race in America and its impact on white people, Black people and the prosperity of the nation.  Some books you might consider: White Fragility by Robin DiAngelo, The Broken Heart of America by Walter Johnson, The Color of Law by Richard Rothstein and How To Be an Anti-Racist by Ibram X. Kendi

At Midwest BankCentre, our commitment to our employees reflects our belief that values and culture are inextricably linked. Culture is the soil out of which all things, good or bad, grow. We have a DICE (Diversity, Inclusion and Cultural Engagement) committee that is charged with fostering the value we place in diversity and inclusion, as we believe it is a source of our competitive advantage and impact. 

Look outside your network when hiring

If the pipeline in your industry isn’t diverse or your network lacks diversity, be enthusiastic about looking outside your normal spheres. I am the ultimate case study in hiring outside talent.  I often refer to myself as an “accidental banker” because I never aspired to banking. 

For nearly 20 years, I have worked to stabilize people’s lives and help them get on the path to social mobility by promoting assets like education, training, life skills, competencies, and the personal networks everyone needs to participate in economic activity. I call these assets “human and social capital,” and Midwest BankCentre believes in promoting them, too. My move to Midwest BankCentre was founded in my desire to have an even bigger impact by optimizing access to financial capital in a profitable manner for all communities.

Further, I know the key ways to achieve success is to have the right players at the table. That will at times mean going outside your own network and industry to hire diverse talent with diverse perspectives that will challenge your status quo. It might make those in your organization feel uncomfortable at first, but it will make everyone better and stronger. Over time, what would it look like for you to commit to increasing racial diversity in your c-suite?

Orvin T. Kimbrough -  Diversity Stats

Diversity statistics

Commit to Recruitment of Talent and Investments in Black and Brown Businesses

So often we limit our ability to truly impact diversity, inclusion and equity by solely focusing on one dimension of how to promote equity with the Black community. I believe we must embrace a refreshed pipeline approach.

Through the years, I have heard a good deal of commentary denigrating Affirmative Action, when the truth remains that if our systems at the front, middle and end were equitable from the beginning, we wouldn’t need programs like these. In our 21st century America, there is still a need for policies and policing (no pun intended) of those policies to ensure that preparation and opportunities are appropriately distributed. Our pipeline to diverse talent is on the other side of a college or technical degree. To the extent that we invest resources, we should use our influence to ensure that this pipeline looks like and represents our region and America.

In the 1990s when I decided to pursue college, I most certainly was a beneficiary of Affirmative Action, which was an intentional governmental effort to get more African Americans into college and beyond. My 1994 class at the University of Missouri-Columbia boasted the most African Americans that the University had ever admitted and, up to that point, we still represented less than 5% in a state that had roughly 11% percent of Black people in 1994.

Let's be clear: Affirmative Action sought to remedy a "marketplace of opportunity" defect. There was (and still is) a near monopoly on opportunity. Affirmative Action simply tried to create the legal conditions to allow African Americans to go as far as their talent and will would take them.

As individuals make their way through the professional ranks, we should acknowledge that systems are still at work undermining the outcomes we want to see—a more diverse executive team. One way to combat this is to strengthen sponsorship programs and tie the compensation of sponsors partly to helping individuals navigate the complexities of organizations. “Despite spending millions on corporate diversity efforts, U.S. companies aren't retaining Black professionals or promoting them to top positions, causing many of those workers to walk out the doors in frustration,” according to a new report. Black people account for about 12% of the U.S. population, but occupy only 3.2% of the senior leadership roles at large companies in the U.S. and just 0.8% of all Fortune 500 CEO positions, according to the analysis by the Center for Talent Innovation, a workplace think tank in New York City.

Orvin T. Kimbrough Black Senior Leadership Statistics

Black Senior Leadership Statistics

Commit to supplier diversity and minority business development

Supplier diversity and minority business development programs were first signed into law by Richard Nixon in 1965 to provide Blacks and other people of color a piece of the economic pie to help quell the civil unrest in urban areas.  Although women and racial minorities are often considered under the same umbrella of stigmatized groups, the fact of the matter is that in the U.S., white women generally receive significantly more supplier contracts and they often comprise close to 40% of all employees in professional settings, whereas Black women and men, by contrast, rarely comprise more than 5% of employees in these same settings.  Typical supplier diversity programs are not focused on truly building capacity and sustainability of Black businesses. They are focused on hitting a spend target.

In other words, the system is mostly set up to determine how much is going generally in the direction of diverse businesses, and minimal systems are in place to authenticate whether Black businesses are winning an equitable share. When there is no real focus on helping these businesses, who are generally starved of capital and financial acumen scale, supplier programs are prone to shell company fraud.

Have an intentional supplier diversity program in place. Ensure that the executive team reviews the metrics and progress at least quarterly. Help build an ecosystem that gives a reasonable shot at success for Black businesses. Set stretch goals for yourself and do everything you can to help introduce those successful suppliers to others within your network to position them for additional business.

In addition to giving existing Black and diverse businesses a shot at serving you or a part of your business, I think corporations need to demand that their law firms, accountants, construction firms, food and logistics, banking and all other key vendors have someone Black and other diverse professionals serve on the project.  This will help move us from a token one or two diverse individuals in an industry to firms viewing their diversity and inclusion activities as an advantage. Furthermore, these individuals will grow, strengthen and expand to establish their own firms, creating a reinforcing loop of wealth creation.

Final point about Midwest BankCentre

While today we are committed to inclusion and providing access to capital for all within our span of care, our commitment to traditionally marginalized communities is a relatively new development in our venerable history. 

Midwest BankCentre (MBC) is St. Louis’s second largest local privately owned bank with assets exceeding $2 billion. A mainstay of St. Louis community banking since 1906, the bank employs a staff of more than 250 working at locations throughout the St. Louis region. Today, we are a nationally recognized leader in community and economic development. In addition to our digital bank that is in 48 states, we have 17 physical branches, some of which are in St. Louis’s most economically challenged communities, while others are in the most affluent.

But, less than ten years ago, the Bank’s narrative was very different.  In 2009, the St. Louis Equal Housing and Community Reinvestment Alliance (SLEHCRA) accused Midwest BankCentre of “redlining,” or withholding home loans from neighborhoods often considered poor, economic risks. Redlining is generally defined as the unethical practice that puts financial and other services out of reach for residents of certain areas based on race or ethnicity. It can be seen in the systematic denial of mortgages, insurance, loans, and other financial services based on location, and that area’s default history, rather than an individual’s qualifications and creditworthiness. Notably, the policy of redlining is felt the most by residents of minority and Black neighborhoods.

The lawsuit alleged that the Bank served the credit needs of the residents of predominantly white neighborhoods to a significantly greater extent than they have served the credit needs of majority African American neighborhoods. I could only imagine the Bank viewed its service area as the South County area vs. the broader St. Louis region. The accusations were biting and direct:

“Lending discrimination deprives communities of access to credit and leaves the residents of minority neighborhoods vulnerable to predatory lenders. This type of discrimination is part of the web of intolerable practices that stripped vast amounts of wealth from communities of color in the last decade,” proclaimed Thomas E. Perez, then Assistant Attorney General for the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division.

In June 2011, the Bank settled the case. And, while not seen that way at the start, the Bank’s leaders and majority ownership now consider these events as “blessings” in disguise and defining moments. It helped to open their eyes, minds and hearts to broader challenges that they were in a position to influence and change. Rather than approach the project as a “series of boxes to check,” which is typical in the business and financial realm when it comes to race, they treated it as any business venture that they wanted to succeed. 

Having served on the bank’s Board of Directors since 2015 and plugged in operationally since August of 2018, I came to understand that the Bank was committed beyond rhetoric to doing our part, that is changing people’s lives by giving them greater access to financial and other resources that give them a shot at winning. What made the difference for MBC was the commitment of our board and ownership group, led by the Stupps and then CEO Jim Watson alongside Alex Fennoy. Alex was one of our first Black employees and leader of our community and economic development efforts. Without the steadfast commitment of these leaders to do the right “something,” it is highly probable that our commitment would have been relegated to “checking boxes.” 

MBC’s story isn't about a wholesale change of people; rather, it is one of wholesale change of heart. It is a story that describes those who were willing to see that systems were broken. They didn’t make excuses or embrace the paralysis that sometimes comes from guilt. They committed themselves to think differently, engage with partners differently, and more than anything else, they oriented themselves toward measurable action. They were thoughtful, but did not overthink or plan. This wholesale change took heart, talent, energy and capital. Given time and continued work, I am certain we will be part of helping lift what will be generations out of poverty through economic equity and mobility.

Conclusion

So many organizations recently have gone on record discussing the importance of creating a truly inclusive environment, from our academic organizations to major corporations. Diversity and inclusion sound bites have never been more popular. The only way diversity and inclusion efforts will prove themselves worthy of this newfound fame is if they are embedded in the hearts of leaders and at the core of enterprise (nonprofit, academic, health or corporate). Equity, diversity and inclusion efforts must have strategic and operational influence and not be solely anchored in human resources or on an island by itself. Again, to achieve momentum and lasting change, we have to rethink how we foster equity, diversity and inclusion across our spheres of influence within industry and community.

Know that the choices you make every day are important and have long-lasting implications. Who you have on your Board matters. How you hire and issue contracts matters. How you hold people in your network accountable for their words and actions matters. When you hear comments that stereotype or denigrate racial minorities, you should speak up. When you see White leadership or Board members tell a Black executive she needs to “prove herself” even after exceeding agreed upon metrics, you now have the language of "micro aggressions" and can speak up. How you expand your network to champion people matters.

This work will take longer than you expect. There will be successes - share these as often as you are able. There will be setbacks. Don’t give up. The work is too important.

It is time to call each other in. This moment is ultimately about sharing power, providing justice, and creating the conditions for creating wealth. Wealth creation is about the ability to own a home, to start or scale a business, to educate our children, and to live a healthy self-determined life. It is about giving everybody a place at the starting line. Let one’s agency, not the color of their skin, decide how fast and far they go. Our children, and our country, depend on those who are in a position to influence our systems and share responsibility and accountability to effect meaningful change.

Our eyes and hearts have been opened by the protests sparked by Mr. George Floyd’s death. And, while the intensity of these protests will ebb and flow, they will not go away until America adopts a new way of engaging with her people. Shared prosperity is our only sustainable course.

Orvin Kimbrough is chairman and CEO of Midwest BankCentre.

You must be logged in to react.
Click any reaction to login.
0
0
0
0
0

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.