Kim Gardner

Circuit Attorney Kimberly M. Gardner

After a few rocky years both internally and externally, Circuit Attorney Kimberly M. Gardner’s office seems to be smoothing out, especially with the recent hire of Marvin Teer as chief trial assistant. At the end of 2021, Gardner’s office held the largest number of pending death penalty cases in the state. The three defendants are Phillip Cutler, Cornelius Greene, and Ollie Lynch. Lynch’s case was de-certified January 7 as a death penalty case, and the Circuit Attorney’s office instead will pursue a life sentence.

“Throughout the course of 2021 it’s become clear that the Circuit Attorney’s Office does not want to capitally prosecute these men, even attempting to hand them off to the (Attorney General’s Office) in November last year,” Elyse Max, executive director of Missourians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, told the Eye. “There are now two pending capital cases in the city and defense attorneys for these cases have indicated that prosecutors are trying to hand them over to the U.S. Department of Justice.”

As a “progressive prosecutor,” Gardner holds sole discretion of pursuing the death penalty for eligible offenses in the city. Just as St. Louis County Circuit Attorney Wesley Bell has stopped seeking the death penalty on all cases in his jurisdiction, Gardner too retains that discretion and could effectively abolish the death penalty in St. Louis under her leadership. However, Instead of stepping into this power, Gardner has chosen to attempt to off-load her death penalty cases to both the state attorney general’s office and the federal U.S. Attorney’s office.

Fake COVID testing thwarts regional containment efforts

Last week, a Florida CBS affiliate’s investigation revealed the “Center for COVID Control,” a Chicago-based company, had been administering fake COVID-19 rapid tests that produced negative results, even when the patient was positive for the virus. St. Louis Ballpark Village and the Central West End have hosted events by this company. There were lengthy lines and each site tested thousands of St. Louisans since the highly-contagious Omicron spike began. The “Center for COVID Control” also did testing at 601 Clark in North Downtown St. Louis, 6219 W. Florissant Avenue in North St. Louis City, and 14282 Ladue Road in Chesterfield.

The “Center for COVID Control” claimed it has partnered with an unidentified “CDC-approved & licensed laboratory.” A USA Today investigation revealed some patients who received negative COVID-19 screens after testing by the “Center for COVID Control” tested positive when they took tests administered by other labs. Public health departments in California, Florida, and Minnesota are investigating the “Center” and its alleged scam operations. Days after local news and national investigations broke, the “Center for COVID Control” shut down its five locations across the St. Louis region.

Meanwhile, the St. Louis region has fluctuated between 35-40% positivity rates since the start of 2022. Testing appointments for most sites are at least a week out. Pharmacies and other stores are reporting shortages of rapid tests as city and county public health officials scramble to set up additional testing locations.

Attorney General Eric Schmitt.

Attorney General Eric Schmitt

Chaos in St. Louis County

Despite the politicized objections to necessary public health measures, the St. Louis County Council passed its mask mandate on January 4, 2022, in a 4-3 split. Council members Lisa Clancy, Kelli Dunaway, Rita Heard Days, and Shalonda Webb voted in favor of a countywide mask ordinance. Tim Fitch, Mark Harder, and Ernie Trakas voted against slowing the spread of the virus. 

But pathetic “Sue Bully” Attorney General Eric Schmitt already has filed a lawsuit against St. Louis County to block the mandate from taking effect. Schmitt, whose wife is a public school teacher and whose own children attend public schools - both of which require masks, has taken advantage of the toxic political climate around COVID-19 in a transparent effort to boost his chances for the upcoming U.S. Senate election to replace Sen. Roy Blunt. We’re old enough to remember when Schmitt supported Missouri Medicaid expansion and launched the fight for legalized cannabis in Missouri after a very public campaign that centered on his oldest son’s health conditions. Now, in a new low, Schmitt has taken his political misadventure to 45 school districts across the state that have sought to protect students, teachers and other district workers from the ravages of Coronavirus. Mark 8:36 “for what shall it profit a man if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?”

At the same time, Council members Days, Fitch, Harder, and Trakas are involved in a federal lawsuit over the redrawn County District map. In a suit before Chief Magistrate Judge Nannette A. Baker, members of the Democratic redistricting commission sued the St. Louis County Board of Election Commissioners, alleging that the map adopted by the Board was unequal in population distribution and violated voters’ civil rights. The Eye further uncovered a curious entangling alliance - Days hired St. Louis Police Officers Association lobbyist and attorney Jane Dueker before Christmas to represent her in the redistricting lawsuit, even though she and other plaintiffs were represented by Dueker’s former law firm, Spencer Fane. 

The Eye has learned that St. Louis County Counselor Beth Orwick has blocked the release of open public records that include civilian complaints filed against St. Louis County police officers. Civil rights attorney Mark Pedroli tweeted, “St. Louis County took the unprecedented position that ‘citizen complaints’ against the St. Louis County Police Department are ‘closed’ to the public. This position is illegal.” Pedroli referenced more than 300 “citizen complaints” against businesses that were released by the County in 2021. He called out the special treatment enjoyed by County police during a time that accountability and investigations into complaints have been questioned.

"Not only are citizen complaints open records, but they're the starting point in deciding whether or not a police department is accountable to the complaints or if they ignore them,” Pedroli told the Eye. “When [consulting firm] Teneo audited the County police more than two years ago, Teneo found there were no policies in place requiring citizen complaints be logged or investigated. Teneo's finding should be totally unacceptable to St. Louis County leaders and the Board of Police Commissioners. Now two years later, the continued secrecy surrounding the exact same issue would indicate they've done nothing to address the audit findings."


St. Louis residents looking to obtain a valid COVID-19 test are directed to the City’s website at

The County’s website is at

You must be logged in to react.
Click any reaction to login.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.