The late Kirby Puckett’s plaque at the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, N.Y., mentions his “ever-present smile and infectious exuberance.”
Is this why he is in the Hall of Fame? Let’s make a quick comparison of Puckett’s numbers to those of one Willie McGee.
In 12 seasons with the Minnesota Twins, Puckett won two World Series titles. He led the American League in hits three times BUT never won a batting title. He had a .318 career batting average with 2,304 hits and six Gold Gloves. He was an All-Star 10 times.
McGee helped the Cardinals reach the World Series three times and his 1982 effort is one for the ages, as the Cardinals topped the Milwaukee Brewers. Both Puckett and McGee were in the 1987 World Series as the teams played one another.
McGee had a lifetime .295 batting average with 2,254 hits. He won a pair of batting titles, was a four-time All-Star and won the 1985 National League Most Valuable Player Award. Throw in his four Gold Gloves and it’s easy to make a case for McGee when compared to Puckett.
While Puckett’s smile was commonplace on the diamond, he also had a dark side that manifested itself with alleged violence toward his ex-wife and charges that he molested a woman in a Minneapolis restaurant. That case was thrown out.
In the meantime, McGee still carries himself with the same kind of dignity that he did when he played the game.
If Puckett was deserving of enshrinement, then so is Willie McGee.
