When word spread across the floor of the Missouri House of Representatives late Friday afternoon – just hours before the 94th General Assembly would by law have to finish its business – that Senate Bill 577, known as “MO HealthNet,” had been passed out of the Senate and was headed their way, a number of Democratic state representatives began to grumble, “No health net.”
Officially, the act establishes the Missouri Health Improvement Act of 2007, modifying various provisions relating to the state medical assistance program and changing the name of the program to “MO HealthNet.”
Republican Governor Matt Blunt has been trumpeting the virtues of MO Health Net, especially since a poll revealed that health care tops the list of concerns among Missouri voters. Blunt, of course, is the governor who presided over the gutting of the Medicaid rolls in Missouri two years ago.
MO Health Net has become Blunt’s and the Republicans’ symbol for having a compassionate health care plan. Few on the House floor Friday afternoon doubted that the Republican majority in the House – they control 92 seats to the Democrats’ 71 – would pass the bill.
The Democrats, on the other hand, call the bill “no health net” because it in effect enshrines the previous Republican Medicaid cuts. It makes only a small and mostly symbolic number of people (roughly 10,000) eligible again for state-provided health benefits, out of the approximately 180,000 people who lost coverage from the previous Republican cuts.
Though the numbers were against them, House Democrats were determined to get in their last licks against this legislation, for the record.
“The people I know personally who were affected by these cuts, this bill does nothing to help them,” state Rep. Judy Baker (D-25) of Columbia said on the House floor after the bill had been introduced.
“This bill makes Blunt’s cuts permanent. It makes pain permanent.”
She then enumerated to her colleagues – who, as everyone knew, already were prepared to vote along party lines – 10 reasons why they should vote against the bill.
Some highlights: It adds a bureaucracy of middlemen who will profit off of public health and is “chock full of opportunities for profiteers”; it does nothing to reduce the burden on hospitals; it doesn’t use all of the money appropriated for health in the budget; it doesn’t address access issues for the uninsured; and it disqualifies Missouri for $1 billion in matching federal funds.
State Rep. Margaret Donnelly (D-73) of Richmond Heights made a similar point about the cuts, using a grisly metaphor: “You took a meat axe to our health care plan two years ago, not a scalpel. If we pass this bill, it would only make those cuts permanent.”
Donnelly also adopted a funereal tone, saying, “There was hope these cuts would be restored. I call this bill the death of hope.”
Though House Republicans repeatedly taunted Democrats with the specter of raising taxes to pay for reinstating more Missourians to public health care, Donnelly insisted that the state budget surplus could bear the $155 million it would cost to “restore health care eligibility for the poor to 100 percent.”
“The money is there,” Donnelly said.
She also was unimpressed with the various improvements in the health plan under SB577 that Republicans have been touting, given that it still fails to restore access to the vast majority of the people previously excluded from care.
Donnelly said, “It doesn’t matter how nice the new house of Medicaid looks, if you don’t have a key to the house you are still health care homeless.”
State rep. Jeannette Mott-Oxford (D-59) of St. Louis took the floor to remind the House leadership about an amendment she had added to the bill, which had been ignored.
“My amendment would have established parity between how poor people are treated and how providers are treated in terms of Medicaid fraud,” she said, insisting that the current bill was harder on individuals, who are capable of relatively minor acts of fraud, than it is on providers, whose claims deal in hundred of thousands, if not millions, of dollars.
“A strong Medicaid false claims act would not run good providers out of Missouri, only the dishonest ones,” she said, but her appeal fell on deaf ears.
The Republican defense of the bill perhaps was best summed up by Cynthia Davis (R-19) of St. Charles, who said, “A lot of people who are poor don’t want to be on the Medicaid program,” which echoes the core Republican theme of self-reliance and expresses the limited ability of most Republican elected officials to empathize with or even understand the poor.
As Mott Oxford summed up another legislative session in Missouri dominated by Republicans, “The problem here is clueless white privilege.”
The bill finally passed the House along partisan lines, 92-67, and awaits the signature of Blunt.
“Missouri’s working parents are no better off today than they were yesterday. A single parent with two children still does not qualify for the new MO HealthNet program if he or she has income over $3,600 per year,” Ruth Ehresman, the Missouri Budget Project’s director of budgetary and health policy said on Saturday.
“MO HealthNet does not help the elderly or people with disabilities who must
spend themselves into deep poverty before they become eligible for the state health insurance program.”
