Michael Butler defeated long-time incumbent Sharon Quigley Carpenter in the Democratic primary for recorder of deeds on Tuesday, August 7. Since no Republican filed for the office, it’s virtually assured that after the November general election, Butler will become the city’s first black recorder of deeds, as well as the first millennial elected to citywide office.
Butler beat Carpenter 27,799 votes (51 percent) to 23,008 votes (42 percent). Perennial candidate Jimmie Matthews got 3,986 votes (7 percent).
“My incumbent has held the post for 38 years,” Butler told supporters after declaring victory at his watch party, held at Chalmer’s Mansion in the burgeoning Old North neighborhood. “She’s been in office as long as I’ve been alive.”
Butler, 32, previously served as the Missouri House representative of District 79 in St. Louis city and Democratic Caucus chair in the House. He was not term-limited, but did not seek reelection to pursue citywide office, running on a platform of modernizing the office.
Butler entered his election watch party around 9:15 p.m., more than two hours after polls closed. He walked in and hugged everyone in sight, then made a beeline to his mother, who had been holding Butler’s young daughter.
“I’m his background support,” his mother said.
Butler picked up his daughter and carried her around as he waited for election results to pour in. At that point, Carpenter held a narrow lead: 1,722 votes to Butler’s 1,305.
Butler’s wife, Erin, repeatedly refreshed the election results page displayed for the watch party. At 9:45 p.m., Erin refreshed the screen with the third update to the election results: Butler had now taken the lead with nearly 49 percent of the vote, surpassing Carpenter’s 43 percent with over half of the precincts reported in. A roar went through the crowd as folks high-fived and hugged each other.
Butler held his little girl in that moment while he continued to stare at the new totals. While he waited for the next update, he ran inside and outside the Mansion, talking to supporters.
Around 10:45 p.m., Butler shouted out, “The final totals are in!” Erin pulled the latest tallies up on the screen to reveal his victory by a margin of almost 10 points.
After the cries and cheers died down, Butler turned to everyone who helped him with his campaign and thanked them individually. He called out the names of his relatives, friends, and supporters who worked on his campaign staff, remarking that it started out with almost no women and now he was the only man.
The evening ended with a bevy of pictures from constituents who congratulated St. Louis’ new – and black – recorder of deeds.
