On Saturday, July 28, at the national convocation “For Everyone Born” held by United Methodist Church’s LYNC (Love Your Neighbor Coalition) and its 13 partner organizations, Rev. Starsky Wilson was delivering the last moments of his sermon. This happened a full six months before the global denomination of the United Methodist Church will have its first special session in almost 50 years to address conflict over LGBTQ+ inclusion.
Wilson – pastor of Saint John’s Church (The Beloved Community), president & CEO of Deaconess Foundation and former co-chair of the Ferguson Commission – spoke about the biblical apostle Peter having a conversation with Jesus, in which Jesus asks Peter three times if he loved him as mentioned in John 21:15–17. He talked about Peter’s frustration over being asked so many times and having to comply that he did love Jesus. Then, Peter later denied knowing Jesus.
Regarding this act, Wilson said, “The responsibility of the community is to make that person right again and bring him back into the circle, because the witness of the entire community is on the line. It’s not just about his reputation.” Wilson then said he was tying that aspect into another one he wanted to bring up.
Wilson began with a request brought up to him by a group, “They said, ‘We’re coming to deal with these LGBTQ issues within the life of the church. We’re coming in the context of St. Louis recognizing the good work you did in Ferguson. We’re wondering if there’s some intersections that we ought to tend to.’”
He paused, and then said, “You can’t leave Peter out and still have a church. You can’t leave Bayard Rustin out and have a Civil Rights Movement.” The crowd clapped and cheered loudly.
Wilson named other notable LGBTQ+ heroes: Barbara Jordan and her push of a liberative narrative within the U.S. Congress, Reverend Pauli Murray’s fight for the modernization of the American church, Ella Josephine Baker and her dedication to the freedom movement, and Kayla Reed’s activism within the Ferguson uprising in 2014.
“And if you don’t know the names that I just suggested to you that center and straddle the line between the racial justice movement and the LGBT movement,” Wilson said. “If you don’t understand that these people lived full lives and we ought to address their whole self.”
A little over year and a half ago, gospel singer Kim Burrell gave her own sermon about the LGBTQ community. The speech revealed a gap between denominations and black churches, all while shows like “Ellen” cancelled her scheduled appearances. In 2015, the PEW Research Center found that 51 percent of African Americans opposed same-sex marriage. Wilson’s views offer a different, more open-minded perspective.
“If you don’t recognize these black folks who wrestled with the matter of sexual orientation before we had language and before we had ‘alphabet’. If you don’t understand the folk who had to wrestle with the reality of not being affirmed in their black community because there were no social categories for them to fully identify themselves. If you don’t know who these folks are, then you need to read another chapter.”
According to The United Methodist Church’s website, homosexuality is “incompatible with Christian teaching.” But a special session of its General Conference, to be held in St. Louis in February 2019, will decide whether this is still true for the denomination and its followers. It’s obvious that Wilson has already made his decision.
Wilson drove the point home that the church needed to do more to bring a light to members of the LGBTQ+ community.
“We’re going to pick up the pen today, and we’re going to write another chapter,” he said. “Some questions you can’t leave unanswered. And some business you can’t leave unfinished. You recognize that what has been written is not sufficient. You understand that there’s some people who’ve been written out of the narrative. It’s time for the church to write another chapter. Pick up the pen, put down isolation, and write another chapter.”
He paused again, took a deep breath and said, “It’s time for the community to write another chapter.”
