Activist cautions against ‘free trade’
By Sanjay Suri
Special to the NNPA
GLENEAGLES, Scotland – Powerful Western nations are committed to developing Africa – as a market for their goods, an agricultural economist says.
”There is talk of the need for action by way of aid, debt cancellation and trade,” Devinder Sharma, long-time campaigner for the rights of farmers in the developing world, said. ”An impression is given by George Bush and others that of the three, trade is the real answer to Africa’s problems. But actually trade is the problem.”
In four African countries (Burkina Faso, Mali, Chad and Benin) whose economies are based on cotton production, U.S. cotton is being dumped and livelihoods are being lost, all in the name of free trade, said Sharma.
U.S. cotton prices are cheap because 25,000 U.S. cotton farmers get $4 billion a year in subsidies, he added. ”This is obviously depressing the market in Africa and other countries. Then they ask farmers there to diversify and go for other crops.”
U.S. subsidies on cotton are more than the gross domestic product (GDP) of several African countries, and three times the amount Washington spends on aid to half a billion Africans living in poverty, he added.
”The recipients of the U.S. agricultural subsidies in 2001 also included Ted Turner and David Rockefeller,” Sharma said.
Ethiopia and Uganda have reported huge losses in export revenues, Sharma said. Earnings through agricultural exports in Uganda were about $110 million in 2001, a fifth of the amount five years earlier, Sharma said. In Ethiopia, export revenues have also dropped heavily.
In January 2002, the European Union (EU) and the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) warned of increased food insecurity in Ethiopia without acknowledging that ”much of the fault rests with their own policies”, Sharma argued.
Talk of developing Africa is just a public relations exercise, he added. ”They know Africa is the future market for the agricultural produce of the United States and the European Union.”
Just 10 companies control the global trade in agriculture, Sharma said. Cargill, the biggest among them, has almost 60 percent of the world trade in cereals, he added.
”They are taking control, and buying from big farmers, and the small farmers are disappearing, even in the West,” he said. ”The U.S. had 900,000 farmers in 2002; in 2004 their number was down to 700,000.”
If Africa is to emerge from poverty, it would have to be through agriculture primarily, he argued. ”If it’s agriculture that is being destroyed, then where is the hope for Africa?”
