That’s what repealing the estate tax would do
By Marian Wright Edelman
Of the NNPA
The debate over whether America should repeal its estate tax is heating up again. The estate tax was first enacted early in the last century, partly in response to the enormous fortunes families like the Rockefellers and Vanderbilts had amassed during the Gilded Age. Reformers argued that government support had played a big role in creating the conditions that helped these individuals earn their tremendous wealth, so it was only fair that a portion of that wealth be returned to society.
Many also argued that hereditary transfer of large amounts of wealth and power was inconsistent with American democracy and values. As President Franklin D. Roosevelt put it, “Great accumulations of wealth cannot be justified on the basis of personal and family security. Such inherited economic power is as inconsistent with the ideals of this generation as inherited political power was inconsistent with the ideals of the generation which established our government.”
But today, at the beginning of the 21st century, when the gap between rich and poor is the highest ever, powerful lobbyists and politicians and the Bush White House want to repeal the estate tax. There is now legislation before Congress to repeal it permanently. The House has passed the bill, and Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist has said that he will call for a vote on it in the Senate as soon as the Senate resumes business after its August recess. This could be as early as September 6.
The estate tax’s opponents falsely try to portray it as a “death tax” that mostly punishes small business owners or family farmers, ordinary American entrepreneurs whose families they allege are often forced to go bankrupt when the tax comes due. But a recent report released by the Congressional Budget Office was reported on in the Washington Post this way: “The image of the grieving heir packing up his hoe as he trudges away from the family farm is just that – a powerful image but not an accurate one.”
The real truth is that the estate tax has always been targeted mainly at those who can most easily afford to pay it: the very wealthiest Americans. As the United for a Fair Economy organization explains it, “Only the richest 2 percent of our nation’s families currently pay any estate tax at all. These are people with estates larger than $1.5 million for an individual or $3 million for a couple. Nearly half of all estate taxes are paid by the wealthiest 0.1 percent of the American population – a few thousand families each year. Repealing the estate tax would result in multi-million dollar tax cuts to the heirs of America’s millionaires and billionaires, concentrating wealth and political power in fewer hands.”
In other words, when you look at the numbers on repealing on the estate tax and Congress’s other tax cuts, you’ll see they only add up for millionaires.
The figures can make your head spin:
* $3 trillion is the amount given in tax cuts over the past four years – mostly benefiting only the wealthiest 2 percent of Americans. If these cuts are made permanent, the number would be $5.1 trillion.
* $1 trillion is the estimated 10-year cost to Americans to repeal the estate tax. To give you an idea of how much that is, when fully in effect, the cost of the repeal of the estate tax for just estates over $3.5 million will be $30 billion in the first year alone – enough to provide health coverage to all 9.1 million uninsured children, to provide Head Start for the more than 3 million children who are eligible but not receiving services, and to lift almost 2 million of the 12.9 million poor children out of poverty.
$106 billion is the amount in additional tax cuts proposed so far this year. Once again, overwhelmingly benefiting the very wealthy, while Congress at the same time is considering freezing funding for Head Start, foster care, and other programs benefiting vulnerable children. As many as 1.2 million children could lose Medicaid. Three hundred thousand people, mostly from working families, could lose food stamps.
There is one simple number you should know: the one phone call each of you can and must make to your Senators. Please call your Senators toll-free today at (888) 233-1221. Tell them: ”Do not repeal the estate tax – which would only benefit the top 1 or 2 percent of households at the expense of millions of our children. Do not accept a ‘reform’ of the estate tax response. It would actually cost the nation almost as much as a full repeal.”
It is unjust to give more money to the wealthiest while our defenseless children suffer. Millions of children are hungry, homeless, left in unsafe child care and poor schools, and denied health care. “Stop providing tax breaks for the rich at the expense of poor children” is the message you must send over and over again until your Senators hear it.
Marian Wright Edelman is CEO and Founder of the Children’s Defense Fund and its Action Council.
