Dear Rev. Wilson:

I want to commend you for voicing so eloquently in this week’s St. Louis American your distress at the violence in our community, and for your candor in expressing frustration and even skepticism of the Oneness event, which was presented as the antidote to so-called black-on-black crime.

Fatefully perhaps, your article appeared on the front page of The American below the featured story of our community’s most recent and tragic tale of such violence – sadly illustrating and illuminating your point.

Your article was moving in listing a litany of frustrations in trying to solve this devastating problem of youth violence, stating exasperatingly: “But, these methodologies are not bringing forth the peace, justice, reconciliation and wholeness consistent with our preaching and prayers.”

But in reading your article, Rev. Wilson, I could not help but draw comparisons between the methodology employed by the ministers heading Oneness, and the methodology employed by the Rev. King and his fellow ministers. I think the difference is perhaps more than just a difference in methodology, but a difference in philosophy and maybe theological understanding.

Two years ago, the Oneness group organized a mass march through the black community promoting pride to purge the immoral behavior viewed as rampant and the cause of the violent anarchistic behavior of black youth. King, on the other hand, organized mass marches at and against the immorality of the white power structure that caused and perpetuated the ghetto and its persistent consequence – black-on-black violence.

When I read your description of the Oneness organizers – “men of faith, intellect, inspiration and commitment” – I was reminded of King’s inner circle’s intrepid intellect; and when you said that Oneness organizers “had gathered for months to plan, prepare, pray and promote a movement to utilize faith, mobilize men and cut crime in our neighborhoods,” it was reminiscent of King’s many intense strategy sessions.

But there, Rev. Wilson, the similarities seem to end.

The intellect of King’s cadre caused them to conclude that the problems afflicting the black community were more the result of external than internal factors and forces. You might recall that when the infamous Moynihan Report – which said the cause of the ghetto conditions was a black matriarchal society – was released (45 years ago), King and the other civil rights leaders rejected it as an attempt to deflect attention from America’s discrimination as the fundamental problem.

Put simply, King’s belief was that the problem was not with us, but with them.

The contrary message resonating from Oneness is that the problem is us, not them. For Oneness was not a march on the city to pressure it to mobilize as much police and other resources to address and remedy the problem of crime in North St. Louis as it does to protect Downtown and white neighborhoods.

Nor was Oneness even a march upon the power structure to provide jobs for the youth in the black community. Indeed, Reverend, I wrote to one of the Oneness organizers to invite them to join the minority inclusion effort to end the racist grip the unions hold on construction jobs. Oneness has been conspicuously absent on this issue, though King was murdered in Memphis protesting about jobs for blacks.

I supposed at first, Rev. Wilson, that the intellect of the Oneness group caused them to conclude otherwise than this and than King, but then that seemed implausible. For certainly the Oneness leaders know that racism still exists, and that the power structure in this city – which sets the policies and allocates the resources that determine the quality of life in this town – is practically exclusively white.

So it seems that the difference between the Oneness leaders and the King era ministers is more than methodology, more than just a difference of using different means for difference times.

Frankly, Rev. Wilson, the courage and conviction with which the King-era ministers took on the white power structure to alleviate the suffering of black people has yet to be demonstrated by Oneness. Perhaps making it, as your article implies, pointless.

Again, I commend and thank you for candidly expressing your concerns.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *