When the United States Senate passed a resolution apologizing for its historic refusal to enact legislation that would outlaw lynching, not everyone agreed.

Eight Republicans refused to support the apology – Senators Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, Thad Cochran and Trent Lott of Mississippi, Craig Thomas and Michael Enzi of Wyoming, Judd Gregg and John Sununu of New Hampshire, and John Cronyn of Texas, already infamous for his veiled threats against independent judges.

Senate Majority leader Bill Frist ran cover for them and their colleagues, refusing a roll-call vote so no one would have to go on record. Frist’s refusal to put the Senate on record makes this apology a sorry one indeed.

Lynching is often portrayed as a fringe activity, terrorist action carried out by zealous racists acting in isolation. That portrait whitewashes the horrible reality: lynching was generally state-sponsored or tolerated, an instrument of reestablishing political control for whites.

The two major parties cut a deal in 1877 – the Tilden-Hayes compromise – to pull troops out of the South and end the post-slavery reconstruction. Immediately, Southern whites acted ruthlessly to reclaim power and to suppress the newly freed slaves.

Violence and state sanctioned terror ruled the South; lynching was the favored terrorist act. From 1890 to 1960, 4,742 lynchings were documented, but the actual number is far higher. Mississippi – with two of the Senators that refused to apologize – was at the top of the list.

Lynching was not simply a nighttime practice of men garbed under the hoods of the Ku Klux Klan. Many were foul civic rituals. Many were draped in the garb of religion, taking place on Sunday afternoons after church with entire congregations – women and children arrayed in their Sunday best – as witnesses.

After the Civil War, the freed slaves were promised a mule and forty acres, but the end of Reconstruction and state-sponsored terrorism broke that promise. Dr. King marched on Washington to redeem the promissory note that had been returned marked “insufficient funds.” Instead, Nixon offered a conservative alternative – affirmative action and better education. But the investment in schools remains separate and unequal, and the Bush administration has fought all the way to the Supreme Court to roll back affirmative action.

Senator Thad Cochran suggested that he need not apologize because he wasn’t involved in lynching. But, without question, his family fortunes rest upon the brutal repression of African Americans. Claims of innocence cannot be constructed on denial of the past.

Now, Cochran joins his Senate colleagues in trying to stack the courts with right-wing judges who oppose affirmative action and in cutting programs for the poor. He won’t apologize for the trampling of justice in the past or stand up for the building of justice in the present.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *