St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department investigators are following up on the case of a petitioner who illegally used children to solicit signatures for the ShowMe Better Courts ballot initiative, according to one Old North resident.
Graham Lane said he was approached by two adolescent girls to sign a ballot initiative petition in April, when they were too young to gather signatures for a ballot initiative and petitioners are sworn to personally witness each signature gathered.
Lane said two officers in regular clothes came to his home recently and said they were investigating a complaint that he made to Secretary of State Robin Carnahan’s office in May. Lane said the men identified themselves as St. Louis police officers and asked him to identify the picture of the person who was listed on the petitioner’s registration form. Lane said the petitioner was not either of the children who approached him for the initiative.
After submitting a Sunshine Law request, The St. Louis American obtained a copy of the ShowMe Better Courts petitioner sheet with Graham’s name on it. The registered petitioner was Satikiya Jones of 4159 St. Louis Ave. The phone number listed on the registration form is not functioning, and no one answered the door when The American went to the residence Wednesday morning.
Secretary of State Robin Carnahan’s office sent a letter to St. Louis City Circuit Attorney Jennifer Joyce on May 6 describing the complaint from Lane.
The letter stated that under Section 116.080 of Missouri Revised Statutes, petition circulators are required to be 18 years of age and registered as a circulator with Carnahan’s office.
“Anyone who falsely swears to a circulator’s affidavit is guilty of a class A misdemeanor, punishable by a term of imprisonment not to exceed one year in the county jail or a fine not to exceed $10,000 or both,” the letter states.
Laura Egerdal, communications director for Carnahan’s office, said the case is now being handled by Joyce’s office.
Joyce said she received the complaint and notified the St. Louis Board of Election Commissioners and “they will look into it.”
Joyce said she could not say any more about the case because it is an open investigation. She said she could not reveal anything about the investigators who approached Lane. Erica Van Ross, spokeswoman for the St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department, said the department is working with the circuit attorney’s office on this.
“These investigations are generally pretty lengthy, but we are involved,” Van Ross said.
The ShowMe Better Courts initiative proposes to change the process in which judges are selected in certain districts. The petition language states the initiative would allow voters to “select all judges through partisan elections.”
This initiative is aimed to repeal the Missouri Non-Partisan Court Plan, a national model for keeping the electoral process and campaign fundraising out of judicial selection. A spokesman for ShowMe Better Courts said it turned in approximately 200,000 signatures on May 2.
Graham Lane, a professor at St. Louis Community College–Meramec, said he was stopped between 4:30 and 5 p.m. on Thursday, April 29 at 13th Street and North Market, near his home, by two girls, both African-American. One, whose age he estimated at 10-13 years, approached him. When he responded, he said, the other, who “might have been a year or two older,” crossed the street.
He said the girl who approached him said they were students at Carr Lane School gathering signatures and, if they gathered enough, “somebody was going to give them air conditioners for their school.”
Lane said when he asked for details about what he was being asked to sign, the girl rolled her eyes and “acted as if she had been trained to respond to this question.”
He said the sheet he was being asked to sign was tucked into a three-ring binder, and she “held it for me to sign so I couldn’t see what I was signing.”
When he asked her to see it, Lane said, he was allowed to untuck the sheet and read what it said. He remembered it had three sentences, and the gist of it was that judges would be allowed to be elected.
James Harris, who led the campaign for the ShowMe Better Courts initiative, said on Tuesday that he had not heard anything about the investigation. Harris referred The American to Nathan Sproul, of Lincoln Strategy, the company who the group hired to gather the signatures.
“Those individuals certified they were of age and legally allowed to work in Missouri,” Sproul said. “If anyone lied about who actually collected the signatures, it is my hope that the State of Missouri vigorously punish them to the fullest extent of the law.”
Lincoln Strategy has a history of working on Republican and right-wing campaigns, including the John McCain campaign for president, and has contested many allegations of voter fraud from former employees.
The signed petitions are now being organized and reviewed by the Secretary of State’s office and sent on to the local election authorities so the signatures can be verified against voter registration records.
On May 26, Missourians for Fair and Impartial Courts Action Fund, which organized opposition to the petition effort, released an analysis of the petition signatures. According to the fund’s unofficial count, ShowMe Better Courts did not collect significant signatures in the 4th, 6th or 8th Congressional Districts. To qualify, they must qualify in each of the other six districts.
Ken Morley, an advisor to the fund, said, “Those leading the signature collection efforts have a history of voter fraud. We plan to inspect every single signature to protect Missouri’s non-partisan system of selecting judges against foul play.”
