Missouri Assistant Attorney General Susan Boresi shows Reginald Clemons the flashlight that tied Clemons and his codefendants to the crime scene of the Chain of Rock Bridge rapes and murders when Clemons took the stand during the evidentiary hearing that the Missouri Supreme Court ordered in his case on September 19, 2012. Judge Michael Manners, special master in the case, listens from the bench.

Pool photo provided by Post-Dispatch

In a stunning decision, on November 24 the Missouri Supreme Court vacated Reginald Clemons’ conviction for first degree murder – and his death sentence – and remanded the case to the state.

The court – which recently added Judge Lisa Hardwick White to the case on a special appointment – was ruling on Clemons’ 2009 writ of habeas corpus.

In 1993, a St. Louis jury convicted Clemons on two counts of first degree murder in the 1991 deaths of Robin Kerry and Julie Kerry, who were raped and forced to jump from the Chain of Rocks Bridge.

The Missouri Supreme Court previously had scheduled an execution date for Clemons of June 17, 2009, until a federal court issued a stay of execution, pending its ruling on a procedural matter. In an equally stunning move at the time, on June 30, 2009, the Supreme Court appointed a special master with subpoena power to open a new evidence phase on the case.

That special master, Judge Michael Manners, found fault in Clemons for pleading the 5th Amendment repeatedly after finally getting a chance to argue for his innocence. But Manners also found that the state did suppress critical evidence from a parole officer, Warren Weeks, who noted that Clemons had an injury consistent with a police beating after his interrogation. This was a violation of the United States Supreme Court’s 1963 ruling in Brady v. Maryland.

Manners ended his 2013 opinion explicitly casting reasonable doubt on whether Clemons’ confession – to rape, not murder – was coerced by St. Louis police. Had the trial court ruled that the confession was coerced, his confession would not have been entered into evidence and heard by the jury that convicted Clemons and sentenced him to death.

“The master issued a report in which he found that the state had violated Brady by failing to produce evidence favorable to Mr. Clemons that a witness observed an injury to Mr. Clemons’ face shortly after a police interrogation and that the witness documented his observations of the injury in a written report that was later altered by the state. The master determined that the state’s failure to disclose this evidence was prejudicial to Mr. Clemons because it could have led to the suppression of Mr. Clemons’ confession, a critical part of the state’s case against Mr. Clemons,” Chief Justice Patricia Breckenridge wrote in a 4-3 decision.

“Substantial evidence supports the master’s findings that the state deliberately violated Brady and that, in the absence of the undisclosed material evidence, the jury’s verdicts are not worthy of confidence. Accordingly, this Court vacates Mr. Clemons’ convictions and sentences for first-degree murder. Within 60 days from the date the mandate issues in this case, the state may file an election in the circuit court to retry him. If the state does not so elect, the case against Mr. Clemons shall be dismissed, and Mr. Clemons shall be discharged on this matter.”

St. Louis Circuit Attorney Jennifer Joyce said work needs to be done before she makes a decision whether to retry Clemons for murder – or rape, for which he was charged, but never tried.

“As this crime occurred almost 25 years ago, we will need to review the state’s evidence, determine the availability of witnesses and reporting officers in the case, and discuss our options with the victims’ family,” Joyce said in a statement. ‘Once we have completed this process, we will then determine the appropriate course of action within the allotted period of time’.”

Clemons remains in state custody to serve a 15-year sentence that was imposed after a 2007 incident with a Missouri corrections officer. Since that sentence was imposed consecutive to his death sentence, he begins serving that 15-year sentence now.

Judge Paul C. Wilson wrote a dissenting opinion, arguing that Clemons’ writ of habeas corpus was based on a claim of new evidence – most importantly, that a previous suspect in the case, the girls’ cousin Thomas Cummins, received a 1993 settlement for police brutality during the same 1991 investigation – that was not, in fact, new.

“Because the facts underlying Clemons’ ‘new evidence’ were in his possession since at least 1995, and because those same facts were reasonably available to Clemons even before his trial, the master concluded Clemons had no excuse for waiting 14 years before claiming this evidence proved his innocence,” Wilson wrote.

Further, Wilson argued there is “no reasonable probability” that the jury would not have convicted Clemons and sentenced him to death had his confession been excluded. Wilson agreed with the special master, who wrote he was “dubious” that the exclusion of Clemons’ confession would have affected the jury’s decision, given that other witness testimony – by Cummins and by Clemons’ co-defendant Daniel Winfrey, who cooperated with the prosecution – established the same version of events.

Clemons was represented by Joshua A. Levine, Andrew M. Lacy, Gabriel Torres, Gabriel Rottman, Donald Conklin, Meredith C. Duffy, Noah Stern and Bashiri Wilson of Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP in New York, and Mark G. Arnold of Husch Blackwell LLP in St. Louis.

“The Missouri Supreme Court upheld Mr. Clemons’ constitutional right to a fair trial,” Levine told The American. “It’s a great day for the Constitution. We are thrilled at the Supreme Court’s willingness to protect the right to due process for Mr. Clemons and citizens everywhere.”

Clemons’ case received tremendous support throughout his lengthy appeals process from the Justice for Reggie Clemons Campaign.

“Since 1991, a fair trial is all that we’ve ever demanded for Reggie,” said Jamala Rogers, coordinator for campaign. “We never got that opportunity with the misconduct of police and the prosecutor. Now, hopefully, justice will come.”

U.S. Rep. Wm. Lacy Clay, a longtime Clemons campaign supporter, said in a statement: “Today’s ruling powerfully affirms my essential arguments regarding his case – police cannot be allowed to beat a confession out of a suspect, and prosecutors cannot be allowed to suppress evidence.”

The opinion is posted at http://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=94495

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *