Notre Dame got a “B” from the Black Coaches Association’s report card, proving that the grades are objective and not subjective.
Keith Harrison completed the study for the BCA and said, “I personally questioned why Notre Dame would give new coach Charlie Weis a long-term contract extension after starting 5-2 in his first season while not offering the same kind of job security to Ty Willingham when he started out 8-0 in his first season at Notre Dame. The report card, however, is not designed to weigh subjective opinions.”
In fact, Willingham being hired had a greater affect on its minority hiring report card grade than its decision to fire the school’s first black football coach.
Detractors who think the BCA Report Card actually hurts the chances for black coaches are out of step with reality. The facts are what they are, when it comes to recruiting and interviewing black head coaching candidates.
For example, South Carolina wanted one man to coach its team. That man is Steve Spurrier. That school and Utah, which would probably never hire a black head football coach, were the only Division I schools that the BCA said failed to document their search process. Those two schools received Fs on the report card.
Of the 119 Division I-A football schools only three coaches – Mississippi State’s Sylvester Croom, UCLA’s Karl Dorrell and Washington’s Willingham – are black.
In Division I-AA, Indiana State’s Lou West is the only black head coach at a predominantly white university.
While 13 of 30 schools that made coaching changes in the last year received either an A or B, more than half earned average, below average or failing grades.
Among those at the bottom end were LSU, Florida and Marshall.
Five schools – Indiana, Illinois, Ohio University, UNLV and Western Michigan – received As. Ohio and Western Michigan, both of the Mid-American Conference, were the only schools to receive an A in all five categories.
You want more objectivity?
Indiana State, which hired West in January, received a C. It was given an F for its search committee, a grade that Harrison said meant no minorities were included on that committee.
