Old grudge yields stupid decision

The Missouri Class 4, District 4 playoff football game between McCluer North and Hazelwood East was an instant classic with the No. 1 Stars taking a breathtaking 41-38 victory over Hazelwood East.

The game was full of dramatic comebacks, last-minute heroics and a brewing controversy. However, the controversy had nothing to do with the game on the field. It has to do with the aborted cable television broadcast of the game, which was hosted by McCluer North.

Charter Cable (CCIN) was scheduled to broadcast the game as part of his High School Game of the Week series with the team of play-by-play man Randy Karraker and color analyst Demetrious Johnson.

In the days leading up to the game, McCluer North’s first-year athletic director Bruce Smith, informed Charter that Johnson was not welcome at McCluer North to broadcast the game and if he was, Charter was not welcome to do the game.

This controversy stems back four years when Vashon High basketball player Malik White was tragically murdered in 2002 outside his home in Jennings. A few coaches and athletic directors from the Suburban North Conference, including former McCluer North A.D. Dave Carpenter, were outspoken about the White’s residency situation in a Suburban Journals column written by Mike Elder.

The outspoken Johnson came down hard on those people who chose to make an issue about White’s residence in the wake of his tragic death. He set up a protest march outside of McCluer High School and accused McCluer basketball coach Kurt Jacob, Carpenter and Riverview Gardens A.D. Mike Walters of racist behavior in his St. Louis American column Hard Hits. Things got pretty ugly about that time.

Anyway, things seemed to have quieted down in recent years as Johnson and Karraker have broadcast McCluer North games in the past few years. They did the McCluer North-Vashon Class 5 state quarterfinal basketball game at UMSL in 2004 and the McCluer North-Hazlewood Central football game last season at Central.

The McCluer North-Hazelwood East game this season was billed as the 2006 Preseason Game of the Year and the game lived up to the enormous hype. However, this instant classic will not be seen by the masses because of a poor administrative decision that did not have to be made. Someone was not wearing his thinking cap on this day.

These Charter games are shown to showcase the kids and give valuable exposure to your school. It is not the time to settle old scores. Nobody won in this scenario and a valuable price was paid my many.

Instead of having the Game of the Year seen by the entire St. Louis area, Charter took its cameras to the John Burroughs-MICDS game. Also:

* McCluer North lost a valuable opportunity to have its No. 1 football program showcased on television.

* Several talented kids from both schools missed out on valuable exposure and possible opportunities to have game film for college recruiters.

* McCluer North could possibly have severed its relationship with Charter for future broadcasts in any sport. There are more than 100 schools from which Charter can choose from to broadcast their games, whether it’s football, basketball, hockey or soccer. Who can blame them if they want to even bother with McCluer North any more, ever.

* McCluer North A.D. Bruce Smith was briefly suspended by the Ferguson-Florissant School District for his actions.

* Demetrious is on the rampage again against McCluer North, opening old wounds and putting the school in a very negative light.

So, Sports Eye begs the question. What in the world was gained by this ill-advised decision to bar Demetrious from doing his job?

This is really a shame. And really so unnecessary.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *